Debate-+Caroline


 * Create a proposition of fact, one of value, and one of policy on each of the following topics: arms sales, terrorism, global warming, excellence in education, age discrimination, and immigration.

ARMS SALES:

-Proposition of fact: The US sells billions of dollars worth of weaponry to numerous "friendly" countries throughout the world.

-Proposition of value: US arm sales constitute a large part in the world economy and thus, should continue.

-Proposition of policy: US policy should allow sales to all nations, to stimulate the US economy.

TERRORISM: -Proposition of fact: The 9/11 attacks on the United States was an act of terrorism. -Proposition of value: Protection of national security is more important than personal liberty. -Proposition of policy: The United States should implement broad national security laws to protect its citizens.

GLOBAL WARMING: -Proposition of fact: Greenhouse gas emissions, particularly carbon dioxide, have led to an increase in global warming. -Proposition of value: Riding bicycles is a desirable alternative to driving cars, in an effort to reduce carbon dioxide emissions. -Proposition of policy: In the upcoming year, the US should enact policies to regulate acceptable levels of car exhaust.

EXCELLENCE IN EDUCATION: -Proposition of fact: The US sets a high standard for excellence in education for its youth. -Proposition of value: Standardized testing is an unfair way to measure student achievement in education. -Proposition of policy: School districts should change their method of measuring student learning.

AGE DISCRIMINATION -Proposition of fact: "Ageism" is discrimination against certain groups or individuals based on their age. -Proposition of value: Every American should be treated fairly, with qualifications based on merit rather than age. -Proposition of policy: The US should implement legislation to protect all citizens, regardless of age, under the Equal Protection clause of the 14th Amendment.

IMMIGRATION -Proposition of fact: Illegal immigration is a drain on US resources, health care, job market and education services. -Proposition of value: Illegal immigration from Mexico is undesirable and illegal aliens should not be tolerated. -Proposition of policy: The US should enact stricter regulatory policies to prevent illegal immigration.